🦥 Slow ride

Validators face public exposure for slowing Solana down

Howdy!

Hope those of you living in Freedomtopia enjoyed the long weekend.

I spent about 40 minutes on Friday deciding whether I could pull off wearing an eagle bolo tie. Which, of course, I could.

Today we’ve got tortuga-ish Solana validators, the unseating of pump.fun, plus news about delayed ETF decisions.

Who’s holding back Solana?

I spent a decent part of today checking out Solana Compass, an independent validator and community-built scoring platform that’s been active since 2021. It ranks Solana validators based on performance, reliability and decentralization.

Some validators seem to have been deliberately slowing down their nodes in an attempt to catch more high-value transactions and increase their profit by widening their transaction intake window. If you've ever wondered why your swap took longer than expected or why a transaction seemed to hang for no reason, a slow validator may have caught you in its dragnet.

According to Solana Compass, one epoch last week ran nearly an hour longer than expected due to these nodes, meaning that every user had to wait longer for their transactions to land. 

It's hard to know how much is optimization vs. exploitation, but with over 33% of stake concentrated in the top 19 validators, the effects cascade quickly. The faster Solana tries to move, the more these sluggish actors slow it down.

The slowest leaders in Epoch 814 included Galaxy, Kiln1 and Kiln2, Chorus One, and several anonymous nodes. All have average block times far above the 400ms target, in some cases exceeding 800ms.

Combatting this, Solana Compass announced on Friday that it will now penalize the ranking of any validator whose block times consistently exceed 420ms. It also factors in decentralization, data center diversity, uptime, skipped votes and even whether the validator has a website or a security policy.

The project aggregates stats from Firedancer UIs across multiple geos and smooths them over five epochs (~10 days). That makes it difficult for validators to game the system with a single successful run. It also de-risks the noise from skipped slots or regional downtime.

In a time when performance differences are often razor thin, public trust is becoming the real differentiator.

Performance is a shared responsibility. With fewer rewards to go around, the spotlight shifts from raw yield to network alignment. It's really thanks to tools like Solana Compass that our community has the knowledge to vote with their stake and the visibility to hold validators accountable.

— Jeffrey Albus

P.S. Fill out our short audience survey and help us build a better Lightspeed. Thank you!

Here’s a chart I think is meaningless but should probably show you anyway:

LetsBonk, a launchpad themed after the viral dog meme and deployed using Raydium’s LaunchLab, passed pump.fun in 24 hour revenue yesterday. Crypto Twitter was abuzz.

We’ve seen this movie multiple times before: A new memecoin launchpad appears to challenge pump’s dominance for a few days only to taper off as pump retains its dominance. Let’s not forget pump.fun still has a reported token launch in its back pocket.

— Jack Kubinec

It looks like the nine firms hoping to issue Solana ETFs are going to have to wait a little longer. 

The SEC delayed making a decision on Fidelity’s Solana ETF in a filing today. That means that REX/Osprey’s SSK fund — which began trading last week under a different regulatory structure — will enjoy the privilege of being the only Solana spot ETF for a little while longer.  

As for all the other Solana ETFs that look like Fidelity’s: “We're still waiting for some sort of movement from the SEC on a generalized digital asset ETP framework,” Bloomberg’s James Seyffart said on X.

The Monday vibes at the offices of other Solana ETF issuers are probably worse than usual: Being first to list a crypto ETF is a big advantage, and SSK saw $11.4 million in inflows on day one of trading.

This perhaps begs the question of why those other asset managers don’t just re-file under REX/Osprey’s framework, but the Twitterverse tells me there are downsides to SSK, which invests at least 40% of its funds in other Solana ETPs.

— Jack Kubinec

A message from Benedikt Schuppli, co-founder of Obligate:

Spread Solana cheer to make perks appear 🎉 

Don’t keep us a secret. Tell your friends and bag some bonuses with the Lightspeed referral program.

  • 📣 3 referrals: A personal shoutout in the Lightspeed newsletter

  • đź’¬ 10 referrals: Lightspeed host and newsletter writer Jack will put you in the One Good DM section of one edition